Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The MMA (After) Hour

NCAA wants soccer players to be more "academic"

The NCAA dropped a bombshell on non-revenue sports and released a proposal (which you read more about here.) which would reduce competitions by 10% and cut spring competitions. This would mean that Soccer players as well as other sports would only have a short season in the fall/winter and now games or practices again until August.

All of this is being proposed due to the fact that the NCAA is "worried" about the academics of participating athletes in the non-revenue sports. Last time I checked the GPA of most Basketball and Football teams at the big universities is far below that of the other sports. If and this is a big IF the NCAA actually cared about the academics they would lessen the load of the revenue sports first. 

We all know the NCAA is all about the Benjamins so lets just agree this proposal is idiotic.

Now how will this affect the MLS?

Star-divide

MLS 

If the proposal goes through this means that those players who do go through college will have played only 20 months at a competitive level. You get 20 months if you figure the season last from August to December. However it usually is shorter for most teams that do not make the post season and that would move the number of competitive months to 16 over a 2 year period. 

If an MLS team drafts one of these players they will be drafting a player who is even more ill-prepared to go through the rigors of an MLS season. Not only will they have to take it slow with these players in terms of fitness, travel and other rigors of a lengthy season they will also have to coach more of the basics to these athletes. All of these factors would combine to make the Draft more like the supplemental draft instead of a draft where you would be getting the best soccer players.

If I were an MLS team who had to wait a few more years for my top draft pick to develop even after 4 years of college soccer I don't think I would want to put most of my focus on the college draft. I would focus more on developing an academy where the soccer season would be 10 months long. Not only would they be getting 40 months of competitive soccer in a 4 year period but they would also not count against the Salary cap.

In the end this proposal while idiotic in its premise if implemented would really shift the responsibility of developing soccer talent to the USSF and the MLS. Which could be good but would definitely create a possible 10 year lag as the academies are just not there yet. 

Comment 10 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

College soccer doesn't develop many MLS ready

players anyway. Time to ramp up academies.

That said, the American university system is becoming a bore. NCAA is all about football and making sure semi-pro football players – who rake in millions for universities – continue to risk their bodies for free and then get punished for “improper benefits” like tattoos.

I love Portland because everyone here takes things so seriously, sort of.

by yepyou'reright on Nov 21, 2011 12:18 PM PST via iPhone app reply actions  

NCAA only cares about Football and Basketball.

Sadly the collegiate sports model is broken in that the emphasis is on those two sports primarily. While I agree that student athletes need to remember that they are only playing because they are students, and there the priority should lie, not future earnings from sports, the fact that they are enforcing this on the non-money making sports instead of the premier programs is ghastly and incomprehensible.

Luckily the academy programs are starting to develop, and hopefully with collaboration with USSF the lack of maturing done at the collegiate level will be negated. Heck, maybe there won’t even be a need for NCAA-level soccer; just go from academy to the pros.

Blazers win!

by The X-man on Nov 21, 2011 12:53 PM PST reply actions  

NCAA's ban on earning money

is a clear violation of federal and state employment and wage & hour laws. If I was an athlete in a revenue sport I would consider bringing a class action lawsuit.

Win or lose, we'll always be there for you.

by johnjahafanclub on Nov 21, 2011 2:32 PM PST reply actions  

interesting

I wonder if anyone has thought of that.

Contributing editor to Stumptown Footy the Portland Timbers SBN blog.

by Ryan Gates on Nov 21, 2011 2:39 PM PST up reply actions  

I'm not a wage and hour law expert

but there is significant scholarly work in the legal community on this issue:

The Myth of the Student-Athlete: The College Athlete as Employee


http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=893059

My girlfriend, her sister, and her mother are all employment law attorneys so I have picked up a fair bit of this stuff from dinner table banter.

Win or lose, we'll always be there for you.

by johnjahafanclub on Nov 21, 2011 3:54 PM PST up reply actions  

Lots of individuals have brought suits against EA for using their "likeness"

All have been tossed out.

Your route, while different, I suspect would reach the same result.

Jag kom, jag såg, erövrade jag.

by Kejsare on Nov 21, 2011 3:05 PM PST up reply actions  

likeness rights

are completely different from wage and hour laws. Wage & hour law states all employees must be paid minimum wage, overtime, and receive meal and rest breaks.

It is clear to me that student athletes in revenue sports are employees. They do what their boss tells them, they labor (a lot), and they earn lots of money (in some cases tens of millions of dollars) for their bosses.

Win or lose, we'll always be there for you.

by johnjahafanclub on Nov 21, 2011 3:50 PM PST up reply actions  

definitely an interesting idea

Would the colleges be able to use the scholarship is legal compensation?

I JUST WANT MY BASKETBALL BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

by Sean in Vancouver on Nov 22, 2011 12:27 AM PST up reply actions  

personally, I think they need to completely redo the NCAA model

I think they need to split the Athletic Department from the University. Run the AD like a Euro-style sports club, with teams competing in all the various sports, compensate athletes based on skill, revenue, or however, and give them some kind of special enrollment status at the afilliated University.

The University gets a share of revenue and maybe rental fees for facilities, the AD gets to use the name of the University, discounted facility use, and a lot more freedom, and the Athletes get paid, and still get some preferred status with the school.

I JUST WANT MY BASKETBALL BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

by Sean in Vancouver on Nov 22, 2011 12:32 AM PST reply actions   1 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Stumptown Footy is an unofficial Timbers blog run by SB Nation. This site is designed to be as inclusive as possible and to cater to all types of Timbers fans. So feel free to join the group and contribute right away.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

216603_10150284064452236_182844932235_7681590_7111194_n_small
Palmer loses embarassing photos of John Spencer, questionable for HOU game

Recent FanPosts

Timbers
Compilation of Timbers 2012 Player Ratings (post HOU)
Kid_bird_small
Hmmm so I'm wrong?
Timbers
Your Player Ratings - 5/15/12 vs. HOU
Pt_small
Dike for the Blues!
Kid_bird_small
Spencer and Wilkinson need to go!
Small
Valencia's recovery
Timbers
Timbers 2012 Player Ratings Combined (post CLB)
Small
Emilio Renteria is a punk
Timbers
Your Player Ratings - 5/5/12 vs. CLB

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Soccer terms/acronyms

Use this handy legend should you come across any word you're not familiar with.

Terms:

 

  • Kit - Team jersey, commonly used for the entire uniform.
  • Footy - Soccer
  • Pitch - Field
  • Keeper - Goalie/Goalkeeper
  • Header - Act of hitting the ball with your head.
  • Assist - Act of assisting the goal scorer.
  • Flounders - Seattle Sounders
Acronyms:
  • RCTID - Rose City 'Til I Die
  • TA - Timbers Army
  • PTFC - Portland Timbers Football Club
Am I missing something? Don't hesitate to email me to ask and I'll update the list.

Related Timbers Links

Like the Timbers? Check out these sites.

Official Timbers/MLS links:

PortlandTimbers.com

MLSsoccer.com

Timbers Army

107ist

Timbers News Sites:

OregonLive Timbers blog

Dropping Timber

Soccer City USA

Slide Rule Pass

Timbers Insider

NW Sports Beat (Timbers)

Timbers Community Sites:

SCUSA Talk Timbers

BigSoccer

Timbers Radio/Podcasts

Strong at Night/Talk Timbers

Soccer Made in Portland

Am I missing something? Think your site belongs here? Let me know!


Managing Editor

Stumptown-lg_small Geoff Gibson

Stumptown-xl_small Ryan Gates

Contributing Editor

289359_664418657558_3702480_34766088_4298995_o_small William Conwell

2011-07-10_13 Andrew Wheeler