Portland Timbers away to Philadelphia: Player Ratings
So I have been meaning to start this for the last month but with the start of school and the need for me to be prepared for it has pushed this out until now. I thought this would be a good stand alone piece rather than have it attached to the recap. I will be giving each player a rating based on a 1-10 scale with 1 being craptastic and 10 being "godlike".
I will also try and give a 1-2 sentence explanation as to why they got that rating. Feel free to give your own ratings in the comments.(I know this game was, as my brother put it, a "bleh" game so this might not be the best one to comment on.
Ratings after the Jump.
Ratings:
(name, rating, comments)
- Mike Chabala - 5 - Did not work well with his wing partner and was out of position a few times but overall did not affect the game positively or negatively.
- David Horst- 7 - Worked well at shutting down any opportunity Philadelphia Union had around the goal.
- Eric Brunner - 7 - Was his usual self and won anything that was around him, even showed the union how a tackle is used effectively
- Sal Zizzo - 5 - Got forward but lacked the quality to put the ball where it needed to be.
- Diego Chara - 7 - The energizer bunny kept going and going and going. Really broke up a lot of attacks and helped out on the wings when they got too far forward. Could have been an 8 if he was able to do more in the attack.
- Jack Jewsbury - 6 - Did enough defensively but did not link up effectively to create much offense.
- Kalif Alhassan - 5 - Great attack and some great switches but really didn't get anything done in the final third where we need him to be more effective.
- Lovel Palmer - 6 - Could have been higher but had some defensive miscues and was not able to get forward as much (mainly due to his wing partner)
- Kenny Cooper - 6 - Did everything that was needed except score the goal. The last 4 games has been a steady improvement for Kenny
- Jorge Perlaza - 6 - Was not as effective in spreading the defense out but that can be attributed in part to the lack of balls from the midfield. Still cannot finish a breakaway.
- Troy Perkins - 8 - Did what he needed to keep the Union out of the net and earned his 6th clean sheet of the year.
- Bright Dike - 6 - worked hard to get into position but still needs some polishing to became a threat to score every time he touches it.
- Rodney Wallace - 6 - Upped the tempo on the left wing and really tracked back well for the tired CM's.
- Darlington Nagbe - N/A - Not enough time to influence the game in his 8 minutes of action but did shore up the D on the right wing.
- John Spencer - 6.5 - substitutions were generally positive and looked like he was trying to get a win rather than sit back and go for the draw. He also pushed the right buttons at half to turn around a listless team.
19 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Troy Perkins
His awful service/distribution on goal kicks and dropkicks is really starting to annoy me, especially after watching how easy Nick Rimando makes it look. I started wishing the defenders would stop passing back to them, because it usually becomes an automatic turnover.
When I write, I write for the Timbers. Contributing Editor of Stumptown Footy
I understand your feeling
But that is not why he is our Keeper. He is there to make the saves and organize the Defense and he is one of the best in the MLS at that.
Contributing editor to Stumptown Footy the Portland Timbers SBN blog.
But an essential part of being a keeper is distributing the ball to start plays, or to steer the ball away from danger
and Perkins is very dodgy at those things. Has been all season.
Still think
That he is better than Steve Cronin
Contributing editor to Stumptown Footy the Portland Timbers SBN blog.
I think his distribution has actually improved throughout the season
But it still isn’t very good.
volatilelyle.com
by almost awesome on Sep 12, 2011 1:04 PM PDT up reply actions
Agreed again
it was desperately poor until about July, and now it’s mediocre. He seems to be making better decisions as far as placement goes, but he still has the tendency to punt the ball into row R more than he should.
We looked like,
we hadn’t played in 17 days. Just some rust. But can we please stop overrating Zizzo? I don’t think I’ve ever seen him do anything but dribble into defenders and lose the ball or send ineffective crosses and bad shots towards the goal, I would much rather have Nagbe in.
Mike Rice: "Camby nearly rejected that with his Armpit!"
Mike Barrett: "Now that would be a fragrant foul."
How many lateral passes does Nagbe get before you will reconsider Sals offense?
Jag kom, jag såg, erövrade jag.
Yeah
I thought the 5 rating means “You didn’t help but you didn’t hurt”
Contributing editor to Stumptown Footy the Portland Timbers SBN blog.
How many assists and goals does Nagbe have?
How many does Sal have? What is Timbers record when Nagbe starts? What is Timbers record when both Zizzo and Nagbe start?
Just wondering. I’m sure the stats are out there somewhere but I’m too lazy to look it up right now.
I want Nagbe, Alhassan, and Zizzo to get as much work as possible… league match, friendly, reserve match, whatever… but right now Spencer has to play the team that gives us the best chance to get points.
by yepyou'reright on Sep 11, 2011 11:06 PM PDT via iPhone app up reply actions
Zizzo
I like his speed a lot but his refusal to look at the goal is becoming frustrating. He had the Keeper on the ground at one point and instead of attempting what appeared to be an easy chip shot (which, at the very worst would have resulted in a rebound) he thought to pass inside which led to the breakup of the play.
We need more swagger around the net. More shot takers, please.
I didn't mean
your 5/10 rating, I mean in general I think people love him way too much and I rather see Darlington get those minutes and experience than Zizzo.
Mike Rice: "Camby nearly rejected that with his Armpit!"
Mike Barrett: "Now that would be a fragrant foul."
From what I undestand there's a contractual reason to keep Nagbe on the bench.
Something about him remaining a generation Adidas player for another year if he stays under a certain number of minutes. Purely speculation, though, and Spencer would never admit to that as a reason Nagbe’s not starting games.
When I write, I write for the Timbers. Contributing Editor of Stumptown Footy
by Andrew Wheeler on Sep 11, 2011 11:21 PM PDT up reply actions
Not True
Check this link out for a interview with an agent.
Who determines when they graduate?
Usually the player himself will determine that, based on how much he plays. If he turns into a regular starter by the end of his first year, more than likely he’s going to graduate. In some cases he may not, but once you’re established in your team, then you’re more than likely going to graduate.
Contributing editor to Stumptown Footy the Portland Timbers SBN blog.
That looks bad
Not meant to have the two .. Makes it seem like I was being a Smart @$$
Contributing editor to Stumptown Footy the Portland Timbers SBN blog.
I like the potential of our three young wings
And their play is electric at times. But man, they can be pretty frustrating at others. Really, we haven’t gotten an awful lot of production from those positions—especially beyond Kalif’s assists and it seems like most of those came in the early part of the season.
volatilelyle.com
by almost awesome on Sep 12, 2011 11:00 AM PDT reply actions

by 


















