Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Trent Richardson Interviews Fellow Brown Brandon Weeden

Draft Strategy: How Should the Timbers Approach the Superdraft? [Poll]

With the MLS Superdraft looming, I was curious about what the people here think the Timbers should do. Not so much about whether they should draft a specific player, but about how the team should approach the draft, and what strategy they should follow when acquiring young American talent.

The Timbers draft eighth in the draft this year, and as many people have noted are looking to make the leap into the playoffs and general Cup contention. While there will certainly be some more veteran related moves coming, the Draft is a great way to add young talent for a good price (great price, if you can get a Gen Adidas player). Unfortunately, the American youth system is still in a stage where it can't be counted on to produce large numbers of elite players, like it can in the NFL. There are diamonds in the rough (See Sapong and Bruin last year), but if the Timbers want an elite player, moving up is likely necessary. This is made even more desirable by the fact that these players will likely have Generation Adidas contracts that don't affect the Cap like normal contracts. In addition, while the Timbers are high on last year's second round pick, Chris Taylor, another player like him would do little to help the Timbers make the playoffs in a difficult Western Conference, at least not for a few years.

Star-divide

On the other hand, the Timbers remain a relatively thin team, especially on defense. Even a few injuries could expose the team, or at the very least force players who aren't ready to take on a more prominent role, which could have very negative effects on a team that now has a tougher road to the playoffs than last year, and hasn't acquired an instant starter yet (though Valencias could have a nice impact as the season wears on). Trading for more picks, either by trading down or sending allocation money, would help the Timbers acquire depth that would help safeguard them in the event of injury, and allow them to compete in other Cups, like the US Open Cup, without wearing their starters out. The downside to this strategy is the MLS Roster limit and cap, which makes it hard to stockpile players.

So, do you see the Timbers as one player away (perhaps an Andrew Wenger), who would be worth giving up something for? Or would you prefer the Timbers either stay put or acquire more picks, building for the future while relying on the current core to take them to the playoffs? Or is there a third strategy you think the Timbers should pursue?

Poll
How should the Timbers approach the 2012 MLS Superdraft?
Trade up. The Timbers need elite talent to consistently compete in the West
18 votes
Stay Put. GW can find a nice piece at eight, while building depth for later in the other rounds
38 votes
Try and acquire multiple mid-first rounders. The team could use some talented depth, even if it isn't quite starter quality yet.
5 votes
Trade down (or out). Pick up allocation money for another international signing or two.
21 votes

82 votes | Poll has closed

Alright guys, I don't believe I have to say this but, just in case, please do not submit anything racist, homophobic, sexist or otherwise not appropriate for even the younger Timbers fans.

Comment 8 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Trade up or out

The guys at the top are pretty much locks to be solid contributors but after the first couple of picks there are enough question marks that I say either trade up or trade out and try and go for another big signing.
If we stay at 8 then we will get a guy that for sure won’t be game ready and even if he developed wouldn’t see the field for 2 years.

by jeffmoe on Jan 4, 2012 12:43 PM PST reply actions  

I disagree

It is possible to get a very good player with the 8th pick (for example, Clint Dempsey was picked 8th).

If you are looking for a guy who will make an immediate impact, almost all of the seniors should still be available at #8, so the chances of getting a player who can contribute right away are pretty high. Last year the players picked with the #9 (Jalil Anibaba), #10 (C. J. Sapong, who won the Rookie of the Year award), and #11 (Will Bruin) picks were all able to get a lot of playing time as rookies. So the facts don’t back up your assertion that we could not be get a player who would contribute for the first 2 years with the #8 pick.

by trk on Jan 4, 2012 7:18 PM PST up reply actions  

Flawed logic

Saying that because Clint Dempsey was picked 8th is like saying you can wait till the 8th round to get a guy like Tom Brady again. You can always run through the drafts of each sport and find studs at every pick in every round. But average it out and the the studs are in the top few picks 90% of the time.

It is even more important in the MLS vs say the NFL because of the $$ issue-in most sports if you trade up it costs you what you trade away PLUS a higher salary for that player. With GA, that cost is mitigated, making it far more logical to trade up if you can and need to.

by smorris793 on Jan 5, 2012 8:12 AM PST up reply actions  

If they can't get Matt Hedges...

I’d say trade out and use whatever they get to splurge on a solid central defender.

RCTID - Stumptown Footy
Moderator of /r/MLS

by Geoff Gibson on Jan 4, 2012 1:14 PM PST reply actions  

Hedges would be a solid pick, especially given the need.

Do you think the Timbers should trade up to try and get him, or stay at eight and see what happens?

And thanks for bumping this.

Oklahoma State will beat LSU in the National Title game by more than 7 points.

by No Pity on Jan 4, 2012 2:17 PM PST up reply actions  

It looks like Hedges should be there at 8

However if for some reason he is not I would trade down for some depth or out for even more depth at the defensive positions (or even another international slot)

Contributing editor to Stumptown Footy the Portland Timbers SBN blog.

by Ryan Gates on Jan 4, 2012 2:20 PM PST up reply actions  

Just depends on stuff we don't know yet.

I know I’m pooping the party, but the problem is we know we’re getting players, we just don’t know who or where they play.

Merritt did say that the focus is defense. I’d rather they got a right back (especially) and/or a left back and then take Hedges. But if we’re looking at CBs than I’d trade up or out.

volatilelyle.com

by almost awesome on Jan 4, 2012 7:13 PM PST reply actions  

yep

not knowing the “plan” and where they are at in talks with other signings makes it tough to say what to do here.

"What and how much had I lost by trying to do only what was expected of me instead of what I myself had wished to do?"
— Ralph Ellison (Invisible Man)

by PDXBuckeye on Jan 5, 2012 5:13 PM PST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Stumptown Footy is an unofficial Timbers blog run by SB Nation. This site is designed to be as inclusive as possible and to cater to all types of Timbers fans. So feel free to join the group and contribute right away.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
Perkins' Distribution

Recent FanPosts

Small
Bornstein on Tigres transfer list; chance for MLS return?
Small
2012 MLS Salary figures
Pt_small
Dike scores against Orlando
Small
Timbers Around the World
Small
Is tonights game exhibition B for season ticket holders?
Small
Bright tonight?
Kid_bird_small
A win is a win...
Timbers
Your Player Ratings - 5/20/12 vs. CHI
Small
How much has our defense actually improved, and at what cost?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Soccer terms/acronyms

Use this handy legend should you come across any word you're not familiar with.

Terms:

 

  • Kit - Team jersey, commonly used for the entire uniform.
  • Footy - Soccer
  • Pitch - Field
  • Keeper - Goalie/Goalkeeper
  • Header - Act of hitting the ball with your head.
  • Assist - Act of assisting the goal scorer.
  • Flounders - Seattle Sounders
Acronyms:
  • RCTID - Rose City 'Til I Die
  • TA - Timbers Army
  • PTFC - Portland Timbers Football Club
Am I missing something? Don't hesitate to email me to ask and I'll update the list.

Related Timbers Links

Like the Timbers? Check out these sites.

Official Timbers/MLS links:

PortlandTimbers.com

MLSsoccer.com

Timbers Army

107ist

Timbers News Sites:

OregonLive Timbers blog

Dropping Timber

Soccer City USA

Slide Rule Pass

Timbers Insider

NW Sports Beat (Timbers)

Timbers Community Sites:

SCUSA Talk Timbers

BigSoccer

Timbers Radio/Podcasts

Strong at Night/Talk Timbers

Soccer Made in Portland

Am I missing something? Think your site belongs here? Let me know!


Managing Editor

Stumptown-lg_small Geoff Gibson

Stumptown-xl_small Ryan Gates

Contributing Editor

289359_664418657558_3702480_34766088_4298995_o_small William Conwell

2011-07-10_13 Andrew Wheeler