Portland Timbers vs. Vancouver Whitecaps Player Ratings: Cascadian Glory Edition
Welcome to yet another player ratings! I'm happy to report that, well, we have something happy to report this week as the Portland Timbers put in an overall valiant effort in securing three much needed points in this year's Cascadian Cup competition. While the regular MLS season remains dismal, at least the Timbers are looking like a strong candidate for taking home the regional cup.
Additionally, it was nice just seeing the Timbers put in an effort that has, unfortunately, been sorely lacking of late. I think this might be the first game in months where the Timbers performed confidently in the forward, midfield, and defensive positions for the entire 90 minutes. That kind of team work is something we need to see every game, home and away, but it was nice to just see it at all after so long.
Here are our player ratings:
Starting XI
Donovan Rickets: 6
Will: Ricketts came up with two big saves (and host of smaller ones) thanks to his positioning, reflexes, and impressive wingspan. His kicks were questionable but when he elected to throw the ball up field he was able to connect well and start a quick counter in a way that Perkins only managed two or three times in his entire tenure with the Timbers.
Kosuke Kimura: 5
Will: Kimura started right back off where he left things before getting elbowed in the face by Tim Cahill, looking solid and playing much more effectively than earlier in the season. He did make one mistake in not tracking Kenny Miller closely on the goal as the wily Scot drifted into his area, but otherwise Kimura has a good game with limited forays into the attack and concentration on defense that allowed Sal Zizzo to contribute effectively at the other end of the pitch.
David Horst: 6 Edit: 5 (I meant for this to be a five, but Geoff and I had a miscommunication. Sorry I didn't get to this until late in the day. -Will)
Will: Horst was Horst. He was agressive, dangerous in the air, and made a few interceptions that could have been very bad if he had missed them. Good but scary play from the big guy.
Hanyer Mosquera: 6
Will: Mosco was, as usual, the opposite of Horst. Mosquera was calm, composed, and had a quiet game in exactly the way you want from your defenders.
Steven Smith: 7
Ryan: Smith shut down his side of the pitch defensively with little help from the wing. He also had the game saving save because of positioning and being where he needed to be.
Jack Jewsbury: 7
Andy: What's impressive about our three central midfielders was that they played a completely different game without Chara in the lineup, and they did so successfully. With the Great Disruptor serving a suspension, all three center mids had to combine more on defense, and they all did a swell job at it. Moreover, Jewsbury and Alexander were incredibly effective in setting up the offense, including assisting Nagbe's goal. Some may disagree, but I chalk that adaptability up to a 250-MLS-game career -- I'm glad he was on the field on Saturday.
Eric Alexander: 6
Ryan: It's great to see the players playing in roles they actually play naturally. He also filled in well for Chara and now forces the coaching staff to question the starting line-up and to try and figure out how to get Alexander more playing time.
Darlington Nagbe: 8
Will: Nagbe was an offensive dynamo for the Timbers on Saturday night. We have gotten used to seeing his quick turns and bursts of speed, but he is now using them to great effect in the space opened up by a more mobile group of attacking players. As the first Timbers player to score in three consecutive games, he has made history this season and if he can continue his current level Nagbe could find himself counted among the Timbers legends soon enough.
Sal Zizzo: 6
Will: Another solid performance for Zizzo leaves me wondering what Kalif Alhassan will have to do once he is back and game fit. Although he was not directly involved in each goal this game, Sal keeps showing why he should be picked for the starting eleven. Zizzo has a solid showing with strong runs and passes and even some good work on defense to round out the night.
Bright Dike: 6
Will: Dike gave the Vancouver defense fits with his movement, strength, and aerial ability, all of which almost saw him open the scoring as he bounced a header off the bar early on in the match. Although his play on the ball was not always what it needed to be, his play off the ball opened up space for the rest of the Timbers attack to work in.
Franck Songo'o: 8
Andy: Franck was my man of the match, and while it's true that his work wasn't great in the defensive half, his presence on the field late in the match (something we haven't seen a lot of, since he's usually subbed off) was a big reason the Whitecaps were unable to create a serious scoring chance in the crucial final ten minutes. His ability to hold up the ball and take it to the corner with little or no help from his teammates took time off the clock and allowed the back line to relax a bit. Oh, and he scored the winning goal and led the team in both shots and shots on target.
Substitutes
Rodney Wallace: 4
Ryan: Did what a late sub was supposed to do and brought on more energy to help see the game out.
Danny Mwanga: N/A
Will: Mwanga was thrust into a role that he has rarely looked good in during his time in MLS: the target striker. Somewhat surprisingly, he did well up top for the Timbers. Mwanga used his big frame well to hold up the ball and provide a good outlet and good hold up play as the Timbers were under pressure late, doing just what the team needed to see the game out.
Lovel Palmer: N/A
Will: Lovel came out, wasted some time, and didn't do anything as far as I remember.
--
So there you have it. Thoughts on how the team played as a whole? Sound off in the comments!
9 comments
|
Add comment
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
You guys are being incredibly friendly to Horst
What I saw from Horst was 1) flailing about, gestating, and bickering about a teammate getting in “his” way on a set piece (Dike) 2) being at fault for the conceded goal by not picking up the scorer (or marking anybody for that matter) while simultaneously keeping him onside.
He had a couple of nice defensive break-ups, but no more than you’d expect from a professional CB. It baffles me why he plays ahead of Futty and Brunner, now that Eric is back from his concussion.
His display after that set piece was not only completely uncalled for (as Dike had both the right and responsibility to go after that ball, not to mention the fact that Dike got up about 2 feet higher than Horst) but was also an on-field sign of the kind of divisiveness we need to expel from the locker room. He wasn’t teaching anybody anything. He was just bitching and making a fool of himself.
Contrast that behavior with Dike’s post-game interview when he was asked about his improved play and he immediately credited the rest of the team, deflecting the praise he has absolutely earned.
Horst earned a 3 at best.
by sagcat on Aug 27, 2025 12:36 PM PDT reply actions
I got to admit I am not a big horst fan
But even I got to say a 3 is pretty harsh…. I would agree with a 5. He had his good points, he was lucky his poor positioning didn’t hurt us more. but all in all it was one of his better games lately with us.
I will say though I dont like comparing ricketts to Perkins. Perkins is a class act, and the fact is hes gone now. Ricketts has played pretty well since being here, so lets just praise him for what he is doing well, not for what he does different than perkins.
by Kazper on Aug 27, 2025 1:57 PM PDT up reply actions
I think a 3 is a bit harsh
but man am I ready to see someone other than Horst playing. I agree with you about that set piece, he was totally out of line getting mad at Dike and I feel like I see him yelling at teammates way too often for my taste. Only the keeper should yell that much. I was at the reserves game yesterday and Brunner doesn’t look ready yet, by why Futty’s not in the starting 11 is beyond me.
by sneevers on Aug 27, 2025 6:07 PM PDT up reply actions
Brunner may be back from his concussion
but why rush someone who recently suffered a traumatic brain injury back into a position where it could be amplified and worsened easily, like EJ last year/beginning of this year? Let him ease his way back in. We can re-sign him if his contract is up, or upgrade easily enough. But let’s not be rash.
Plus after that long off the pitch, his conditioning was probably nowhere near a quick return to the XVIII, let alone the XI.
Blazers win!
by The X-man on Aug 27, 2025 11:34 PM PDT up reply actions
He looked okay
in the reserve game the other day despite the 3-1 loss. One of those was a complete fluke. I think he’ll be back for the second Colorado game or the one after that. He’s getting pretty close.
by burnsbabe on Aug 28, 2025 1:33 AM PDT up reply actions
minus one to everyone who was back for that corner
That was laughable d. If Miller didn’t bury that the other guy standing on that side of the box totally alone would have. I know it was a broken play, but wtf?
by almostawesome on Aug 27, 2025 2:59 PM PDT via mobile reply actions
I wouldn't have had Kimura
as the lowest scoring player out there, I thought he won nearly every tackle he went for, nothing much came down his side at all.
I don’t miss Perkins as much as many others, but Rickets is going to throw one of those shots in the net one day soon, the ones that look like standard saves but seem to bounce off him at weird angles. They’ve been going wide or over so far (70 min here and v Toronto) one will go in soon. Also somewhat unorthodox in his play leading to Smith’s clearance.
Goal’s on Horst for me (well as well as the ref) it’s not a random thing here, when that ball gets cleared out by Smith, the guys should be looking to push out to a line somewhere around the penalty spot. It’ll be a training ground thing, you certainly don’t get told to stand on the edge of the 6 marking no-one
by mccusk on Aug 27, 2025 3:52 PM PDT reply actions
Good point, there were zero off-sides calls the whole game. Could be something we start to think to use on occasion.
by SEDave on Aug 28, 2025 7:51 AM PDT up reply actions
I blame Horst more than Kimura for the goal
Although Kimura was displaying his usual bad habit of drifting too far into the center and leaving attackers open out wide, the real problem on this play was Horst. Horst was guarding Miller until just before Miller scored when he randomly drifted over towards Rickets leaving Miller open. Not only that, but Horst was way behind all the other defenders throughout the play as if he thought it was his job to keep Miller onside. Horst just wasn’t coordinating with his teammates at all and the goal was scored as a result.
by trk on Aug 27, 2025 4:02 PM PDT reply actions
Something to say? Choose one of these options to log in.

- » Create a new SB Nation account
- » Already registered with SB Nation? Log in!

by Geoff Gibson on 










